In a surprising 3-2 decision, the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that environmental plaintiffs whose property is not contaminated may nevertheless be able to recover “stigma damages,” which include decreased property values resulting from negative perceptions associated with property that is contaminated or near contaminated property. In Chestnut v. AVX Corporation (Aug. 5, 2015), the Court reversed the dismissal of a lawsuit which alleged that, even though plaintiffs’ property was not contaminated, it was in such proximity to a contaminated area that it had been devalued. Based upon legal authorities dating back to the early 1970s, environmental practitioners in South Carolina have long believed that typical causes of action for contamination – trespass, nuisance, strict liability, and negligence – require plaintiffs to allege and prove that their property has been contaminated and that “stigma damages” are not recoverable. The Chestnut majority ruled, however, that “creation of a factual record will allow us to decide whether to adopt a ‘no stigma damages rule;’ and ‘all stigma damages rule;’ or a modified rule.” The full decision is available here.
- Why
Wyche-
-
-
-
The Wyche Way
A Different Kind of Relationship
Wyche is built for clients who deserve more than an ordinary law firm.
-
-
-
- What
We Do-
-
-
-
What We Do
Our Practice Areas
Wyche participates in landmark litigation and serves as counsel on cutting-edge transactions through its five core practice areas.
-
-
-
- About Wyche
-
-
-
-
About Wyche
In a Class of Its Own
Wyche attorneys embrace the challenge and stimulation of practicing with a remarkably accomplished group of attorneys, and the satisfaction and pride that comes from knowing we are part of a firm that gives clients the best possible service.
-
-
-
- Wyche Insights
-
-
-
-
Wyche Insights
Attorneys with Intellectual Firepower
Wyche attorneys are consistently recognized as industry and community leaders and honored with prestigious awards. We are proud of these accomplishments, but applying our talents to serve our clients and the community is what really motivates us. Wyche attorneys share their intellectual firepower with thoughtful articles, newsletters, and blogs that keep clients and colleagues informed.
-
-
-
- Community Leadership
-
-
-
-
Community Leadership
SHAPING OUR COMMUNITY
For over 95 years, Wyche has provided leadership that has helped drive our region’s growth and success.
-
-
-
- Careers at Wyche
-
-
-
-
Careers at Wyche
Handpicked. One by One.
We don’t hire large classes of lawyers and hope that most turn out well. Instead, Wyche lawyers are handpicked, one by one, to join this firm because each has the skills and accomplishments to be a part of our effort to provide unmatched service to our clients.
-
-
-